Articles & Papers

Articles & Papers

A collection of ironwork related articles for conservators and heritage ironworkers.

New articles added as we find them.  If you have any proposals for additions to this page please contact us.


Investigating Failure Mechanisms in Historical and Modern Wrought Irons During Tensile Testing with Acoustic Emission Monitoring and Imaging

Kutsi Akcicek, Jiaxu Zuo, Heather Viles, and Sinan Acikgoz

Department of Engineering Science, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK; School of Geography and the Environment, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK

ABSTRACT

Wrought irons from the 14th (Salisbury Cathedral), 18th (Blenheim Palace), and 20th (Topp & Co., recently re-rolled) centuries are subjected to tensile testing. Failures are investigated using acoustic emission (AE) data, digital image correlation (DIC) strain measurements, post-mortem scanning electron microscopy (SEM), and micro-computed tomography (micro-CT). Analysis of the AE results using principal component analysis and DBSCAN clustering identified three major failure mechanisms, differentiated by the signal’s peak frequency. By analysing the datasets comparatively, three mechanisms are identified and attributed to specific frequency ranges: plastic deformation (35–87 kHz), debonding (125–156 kHz), and fracture (197–298 kHz). The modern specimens exhibited ductile failure, with post-yield behaviour characterised by plastic deformations. In contrast, the historical irons exhibited defect-driven failure, characterised by local strain concentrations dominated by debonding and fracture events. Visual inspections and micro-CT segmentation analyses demonstrated that the failure events were due to the presence of transverse slags, oxide products, and voids. The influence of these defects is systematically evaluated to provide new insight into how macro-mechanical properties are influenced by micro-mechanical failure mechanisms in three different wrought irons.

Download PDF

IN-SITU ACOUSTIC EMISSION MONITORING OF ACCELERATED CORROSION OF WROUGHT IRON

Kutsi Akcicek 1) , Sinan Acikgoz 1) and Heather Viles 2)

1) Department of Engineering Science, University of Oxford, Oxford, United Kingdom 2) School of Geography and the Environment, University of Oxford, Oxford, United Kingdom

ABSTRACT

Wrought iron bars, with attached waterproofed acoustic emission (AE) sensors, were subject to accelerated degradation in a corrosion chamber. During the transition from the wet to dry stages of the sample, a significant rise in AE hits was observed. Conversely, in fully dry or wet stages, fewer AE hits were detected. Based on the AE activity between transition stages, the results support existing theories of atmospheric corrosion of iron and the significance of wet to dry cycles in this process. Waterproofing of sensors for in-situ corrosion studies has also shown to be viable without causing damage to the sensor itself.

Download PDF from Oxford’s website

Student ‘Metals’ Essay Prize winner 2023

We awarded Alexandra Dziegiel a prize for this impressive essay on historic iron, its deterioration and conservation.

Metals Essay Prize 2023 (.pdf)

Architectural Ironwork – Coatings & Colour

Patrick Baty delivered this presentation at our seminar on Colour & Finish in London on 15th November 2018

Architectural Ironwork - Coatings & Colour by Patrick Baty (.pdf)

Bath Ironwork

Article in the Bath Magazine about local heritage ironwork: https://issuu.com/mcpublishing/docs/the_bath_magazine_may_2018/40

Lead and You

By Matthew Boultwood and Jo Adkins

Lead and You
Lead_and_You-generalversion-16-Jul-2013.pdf (1.08 MB)

Lead is a very useful and versatile material, in traditional metalwork it is often used for fixings, decorative details and in some coatings.  Lead paints for example give an outstanding and durable finish but its removal is a noxious process

 

The Use of Colour on Architectural Ironwork

By Patrick Baty

The Use of Colour on Architectural Ironwork
TheUseOfColourOnArchitectualIronwork_by_PatrickBaty.pdf - Version 1 (47.67 KB)

This paper is based on the text of a lecture given by Patrick Baty at "From Foundry and Forge", an International Ironwork Symposium held at the Victoria and Albert Museum on 28th October 1994.

 

Development of riveting technology through an analysis of Belgian patents (1830-1940)

By Quentin Collette, Ine Wouters, Corentin De Favereau, Arnaud Peters

Development of riveting technology through an analysis of Belgian patents (1830-1940)
Quentin_Collette_SAHC2012_051.pdf (804.15 KB)

The development of riveting technology in iron and steel structures in the 19th and 20th centuries were highly promoted by patents. Although riveting was widely used in buildings and civil engineering structures, little information about the development of this technology – how rivets were manufactured, various installation techniques – is available in literature. This paper discusses a database of patents related to riveting technology that was created to better understand the innovations in riveted connections and their technological evolution. The database includes patents relating to rivets registered in Belgium between 1830 and 1940.

 

Evolution of historical riveted connections: joining typologies, installation techniques and calculation methods

Q. Collette, I. Wouters & L. Lauriks
Department of Architectural Engineering (ARCH), Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Belgium

Evolution of historical riveted connections: joining typologies, installation techniques and calculation methods
STREMAH_2011_Rivets_by_Quentin-Collette.pdf (318.12 KB)

Riveting was one of the major joining techniques used for the assembly of iron and steel structures. Being widely used since 1860, today most of the existing riveted structures need maintenance and possibly strengthening.

This research aims to improve the existing knowledge on this type of fasteners in order to stimulate less intrusive interventions during renovation, respecting the historical character of these structures.

 

Morphogenesis of the Theory and Design Principles of Riveted Connections in Historical Iron and Streel Structures

By Quentin Collette

Morphogenesis of the Theory and Design Principles of Riveted Connections in Historical Iron and Streel Structures
SAHC-2012_050-by-Quentin-Collette.pdf (5.25 MB)

This paper provides insights into the design principles of historical riveted joints by examining the content of the former calculation methods and their evolution over time. By investigating these theoretical foundations, this study reveals possible design errors and clarified the design choices made by engineers of that time.

SHOP